Bordeaux from small wineries rival those of grand estates — at a fraction of the price
by David Lawrason
In May, I spent 10 days in Bordeaux, France, with fellow wine enthusiasts who had bid high for the pleasure of a tour that took in France’s great châteaux. (The auction, for the record, took place during last year’s Gold Medal Plates chefs’ competition, which raises funds for Canada’s Olympic athletes. This year’s food and wine soiree takes place November 16 at the National Arts Centre, www.goldmedalplates.com). Our excursions through the Médoc, Saint-Émilion/Pomerol, Graves, and Sauternes landed at many impressive grand cru classé, or top-ranked, wine estates. The wines were splendid, the aura of the properties was splendiferous, and the wine prices were — well — stratospheric. A barrel sample of a stunning premier Grand Cru Classé 2009 Château Cheval Blanc was priced at about $500 a bottle. Given the acclaim of the pitch-perfect 2009 vintage, it could fetch up to $1,500 by the time it passes through commercial markups and government levies to show up at the LCBO in 2012. (The unacclaimed 2006 currently lists at $1,099.)
So, yes, we were awestruck and very fortunate. But when we weren’t sipping once-in-a-lifetime bordeaux reds, we were actually buying and drinking “petits chateaux” from less vaunted vintages. And though they lacked the swooning refinement and soul-probing depth of their grand cru peers, they somehow demonstrated more personality and individuality — for far less money. The 2006s are authentic, slightly less ripe, and more tannic. The 2007s are lighter, fruitier, and more charming, without the flavour depth of 2006 and the terrific structure and deep fruit of the 2005s. (I love the 2005s.)













